Mexican restaurants

Original Nottingham Pizza

3.9 118 reviews 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM 2460 Baltimore Pike, Oxford, PA 19363, United States

Discover this place

If you're searching for a vibrant culinary experience, look no further than Original Nottingham Pizza. Nestled in Oxford, PA, this gem boasts a unique blend of Mexican flavors that leaves diners craving more. Customers rave about the pizza roll and the Tika quesadilla, which many describe as "next level." The ambiance is warm and inviting, reminiscent of a true Mexican eatery, and the staff are praised for their authenticity and attentiveness.

With an extensive menu filled with enticing options like carnitas sopes, big quesa birria, and enjoyable tacos, there's something for everyone. Customer reviews highlight both dine-in and takeout experiences, emphasizing the consistent quality of the dishes. Pricing is another advantage, making it an affordable choice for delicious food.

Original Nottingham Pizza doesn’t just serve meals; it creates a community around good food. Whether you're sampling delicious al pastor tacos or indulging in a hearty burrito, each visit promises satisfaction and a reason to return. Many reviewers have found their new favorite spot—will you be next?

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Original Nottingham Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Original Nottingham Pizza

3.9

118 reviews

100%

19%

11%

27%

Review highlights

Based on 118 reviews

Original Nottingham Pizza consistently receives praise for its authentic Mexican-inspired menu and flavorful dishes, including standout items like quesadillas, burritos, and tacos. Customers appreciate the variety offered, catering well to both dine-in and delivery preferences. The quality and taste of the food are frequently highlighted, with many noting that the flavorful salsas and well-prepared ingredients elevate the dining experience. Service is another strong point, described as friendly and attentive, complementing the overall welcoming atmosphere. Affordability and generous menu options also contribute to the brand’s positive reputation. Overall, Original Nottingham Pizza is regarded as a reliable choice for Mexican cuisine with a pizza twist, earning loyal repeat customers.

Josh Dubrow

Jun 06, 2025

This place has a great Mexican vibe, and honestly, no complaints here! The staff keeps it real, and the food more than makes up for it. The pizza roll was incredible, and the Tika quesadilla? Absolutely next level. Can't wait to come back for more!

Hannah Subach

Apr 30, 2025

Love this place to eat ! Prices are good ! Many choices on the menu. I dine in or do take out/delivery Pizza is delicious. I haven’t gotten anything that wasn’t good. I highly recommend checking it out if you haven’t yet, I give this place a 10/10

Patrick Kemper

Apr 25, 2025

Perfect food. Temps are great, everything a pizza place should be

G Naylor

Apr 23, 2025

Best Mexican food in my area. Try it all! The service is great the food is better. Carnitas sopes with that green sauce is my current addiction. Big quesa birria is crazy good! Tacos, tortas, burritos, and anything else. This place cares and I care to keep coming back. Thanks again!

Matthew Conley

Apr 21, 2025

I got a chicken burrito and al pastor tacos yesterday. It was amazing. yall have really stepped it up. The red and green salsa was . My fat ass was pleased.

alohoski

Apr 07, 2025

We stopped in while on the way from Holiday shopping. It was out first time, the gentleman at the counter was very nice. We tried the chicken nachos and a cheese and pepperoni pizza. The nachos didn't get soggy, the jalapenos were soo good, the chicken was well cooked and the portion was generous. The pizza was also very good. Plenty of cheese, the right amount of sauce and perfect crust. Will return to try the tacos and pizza roll.

silverspoon819

Apr 01, 2025

I come here for the Mexican food. I haven’t tried the pizza. The Mexican food is delicious. Made to order so it’s fresh and hot.

kevin maginn

Mar 21, 2025

Fantastic Mexican food at a great price